2003-04 Fleer Mystique features a 120-card base checklist with 40 serial-numbered rookies. Inserts include Secret Weapons, Shining Stars, Awe Pairs and Rare Finds, alongside Gold, printing plate and die-cut rookie parallels.
Hobby boxes contain 20 packs of four cards and one mystery pack per box. The printed box advertises memorabilia cards at 1:10 packs and autographs at 1:120 packs; these rates apply to the product groups.
| # | Player / Subject | Team | PSA Pop | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 51 | Dan Dickau | Atlanta Hawks | — | |
| 52 | Baron Davis | New Orleans Hornets | — | |
| 53 | Bruce Bowen | San Antonio Spurs | — | |
| 54 | Amare Stoudemire | Phoenix Suns | — | |
| 55 | Michael Finley | Dallas Mavericks | — | |
| 56 | Jamal Mashburn | New Orleans Hornets | — | |
| 57 | Pau Gasol | Memphis Grizzlies | — | |
| 58 | Shawn Marion | Phoenix Suns | — | |
| 59 | Rasheed Wallace | Portland Trail Blazers | — | |
| 60 | Chris Webber | Sacramento Kings | — | |
| 61 | Rodney White | Denver Nuggets | — | |
| 62 | Tayshaun Prince | Detroit Pistons | — | |
| 63 | Yao Ming | Houston Rockets | — | |
| 64 | Latrell Sprewell | Minnesota Timberwolves | — | |
| 65 | Aaron McKie | Philadelphia 76ers | — | |
| 66 | Bonzi Wells | Portland Trail Blazers | — | |
| 67 | Hedo Turkoglu | San Antonio Spurs | — | |
| 68 | Ray Allen | Seattle SuperSonics | — | |
| 69 | Matt Harpring | Utah Jazz | — | |
| 70 | Paul Pierce | Boston Celtics | — | |
| 71 | Darius Miles | Cleveland Cavaliers | — | |
| 72 | Chris Wilcox | Los Angeles Clippers | — | |
| 73 | Steve Nash | Dallas Mavericks | — | |
| 74 | Antawn Jamison | Dallas Mavericks | — | |
| 75 | Juan Dixon | Washington Wizards | — | |
| 76 | Peja Stojakovic | Sacramento Kings | — | |
| 77 | Antonio Davis | Toronto Raptors | — | |
| 78 | Kenny Thomas | Philadelphia 76ers | — | |
| 79 | Elton Brand | Los Angeles Clippers | — | |
| 80 | Gilbert Arenas | Washington Wizards | — | |
| 81 | Mickael PietrusRC | Golden State Warriors | — | |
| 82 | Keith BogansRC | Orlando Magic | — | |
| 83 | Dahntay JonesRC | Memphis Grizzlies | — | |
| 84 | Darko MilicicRC | Detroit Pistons | — | |
| 85 | Torraye BraggsRC | Houston Rockets | — | |
| 86 | Troy BellRC | Memphis Grizzlies | — | |
| 87 | Maciej LampeRC | New York Knicks | — | |
| 88 | Kendrick PerkinsRC | Boston Celtics | — | |
| 89 | Kirk HinrichRC | Chicago Bulls | — | |
| 90 | Jason KaponoRC | Cleveland Cavaliers | — | |
| 91 | Udonis HaslemRC | Miami Heat | — | |
| 92 | James LangRC | New Orleans Hornets | — | |
| 93 | Willie GreenRC | Philadelphia 76ers | — | |
| 94 | Travis OutlawRC | Portland Trail Blazers | — | |
| 95 | Nick CollisonRC | Seattle SuperSonics | — | |
| 96 | Jarvis HayesRC | Washington Wizards | — | |
| 97 | Boris DiawRC | Atlanta Hawks | — | |
| 98 | Chris BoshRC | Toronto Raptors | — | |
| 99 | Cleveland Cavaliers | — | ||
| 100 | Zarko CabarkapaRC | Phoenix Suns | — |